Posted in uncategorized

Stop this refrain, The spirit or resilience of Mumbai!


The character and space of Mumbai change every nano-second.  As a city, Mumbai is constantly on its toes and access to basic and solid ground infrastructure should be the topmost priority when we look at the growing number of commuters in lakhs that occupy every limit and space or the lifeline, local trains.

The stampede and near collapse of the 11 meter wide Elphinstone bridge on Friday leave us with a sense of déjà-vu in Maximum City and something many of us who ever stayed in the city was sensing to come. Unfortunately, tragedy struck where 22 innocent lives were robbed.

Studies showcase that on an average more than one lakh use the 117-year old bridge and the average commuters visiting the Elphinstone area amounts to 10 lakhs a day. The numbers tell an entire story on the toll that the bridge takes and it’s not an issue restricted to just one but several stations in the city. It’s apathy at its best where several railways suffer from such a burden.


Image credit: Google/


The fact remains that thousands and lakhs flock to the city every day in search of a better life and opportunity. High time for the BMC and the Government to answer the pressing questions on the why’s of a city that once aspired to become the Shanghai of India is suffering from a dearth of safe infrastructure. The answer doesn’t lie in the 3,600 crores Shivaji Maharaj statue. Mumbai as a city in spirit and soul need basic infrastructure and amenities so that the people and visitors can securely move around from one part to another.

In the light of incidents taking place such as the crumbling of railway infrastructure or the city coming down to its knees every monsoon, arguments such as The Spirit or resilience of Mumbai is almost an insult to commoners. It’s high time that the BMC show accountability in giving its citizens a dignified life. One cannot afford to lose life in exchange for a compensation of 5 lakhs. It’s a slap on the face of innocent people. It makes one wonder, what is the fault of the people?

The time I stayed in the city, there were instances where I walked past the Elphinstone bridge and every time there was a fear that mayhem will strike due to the lack of space and inability to sustain the growing population pressure. Let me give one small example, every time a local reaches platform No 1, commuters jostle for space on the bridge and recklessly run down the stairs where there is a huge risk of stampede. It’s the sorry state of not just one but several railway stations in the city.

There are questions on the enlarging of Elphinstone bridge in the present case scenario and why the project to the tune of Rs 11-12 crores that were sanctioned in the budget couldn’t be implemented. It’s a clear case of apathy, red-tapism, and corruption among the decision-makers. The BMC is considered to be the richest municipal body in Asia and still, nothing has been done to give dignity and ensure safety. Chasing immigrants with the slogan, ‘Bhaiya Bhagao’ is not the answer and it only shows how they mask their short-sightedness by blaming poor migrants or looking for scapegoat.

The reality is that the Shiv Sena, Congress, and the BJP are equally responsible for the neglect and constant crumbling of infrastructure that not only claimed lives but sinking the city further down the drain. Each one of these political parties have ruled Mumbai at some point or the other where every single day people live constantly on the edge.

Bureaucracy has gone from bad to worse in the city and infrastructure is getting worse by the day coupled with a lack of minimum standard in mounting projects. The least that policymakers can and must do: Raise standards and norms first before speaking about bullet train or 3,600 crores statue.

Basic and rooted infrastructure, security and adhering to norms is what a premiere city like Mumbai needs and the financial capital of India cannot afford to lose this game due to apathy and corruption. Stop the refrain of resilience or spirit every time mayhem struck!






Work-in-progress, seeker and bundle of contradictions. Stubborn and Refusal to grow up and constantly in search of myself, I blurt it out on my space. Drop in and share some love. Indian by choice.

10 thoughts on “Stop this refrain, The spirit or resilience of Mumbai!

  1. Agreed that our mega cities need a relook at basic infrastructure. And while chasing immigrants is not an option, de-urbanization and creation of equal opportunities in hometowns can bring the pressure down. All said and done, I strongly believe our people are turning foolish, less of a human as days pass by. When it rains, it’s instinctive to run for shelter, but when the shelter looks full, instead of “swalpa adjust maadi”, common sense should’ve prevailed and people should have looked for shelter elsewhere. Nothing’s more important than saving your own life, right? Yet, that’s something we don’t value. Life – ours or theirs. And we lack common sense as a nation.

    1. Agree with it. I have always believed in giving people basic infrastructure to reduce the pressure in several metros. Yes it can happen where cities get crowded but at the same time this bridge is used by growing number of commuters. The issue is much bigger here and the onus I believe fall on BMC and the implementtion of extension since everyday lakh come to Mumbai. De-urbanization is one of the solution where there is need for solid plans for the nextd decade or beyond.

  2. This was one of the most unfortunate events in Mumbai – one for which e cannot blame any outsiders but the apathy of our own administrators, who failed to recognize the need to provide appropriate infrastructure for the commuters. Mumbai traffic is getting from bad to worse each day. Every construction takes years to complete and basic infrastructure needs such as footpaths, footbridges and pot hole covers are not catered to in most places. High time someone takes up the onus and responsibility.

    1. Unfortunately, its an incident that has been boiling and looking at the threat to safety at the bridge. The worse is the lack of safe infrastructure for the people and the numbers are growing. The worse is politicians shifting the blame on migrants and high time to come with five or 10 year plans to make the city better. Sad to see people hiding in their ivory tower.

  3. A day will come when all of Mumbai’s citizens will rise against the authorities. We have become so used to the apathy that it takes something as gruesome as this incident to shake us up, but not as much as is needed to be shaken to come together and demand our rights from the authorities. That day will come soon though. The authorities need to work fast to make sure they give safe and proper infrastructure to Mumbai citizens.

    1. It’s high time that people should rise against such apathy and corruption costing lives. The blame shouldn’t be on people coming from other states. Time for people sitting on their laurels to buck up rather than with such weak infrastructure costing lives in Mumbai. They need to be accountable and be transparent on where the money is going with BMC being the richest body in Asia.

    1. It was beyond shocking Maniparna and something that accumulated where innocent citizens paid with their lives. Exactly, the various Governments should pay heed and bring changes to ensure safety.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s