Posted in uncategorized

Her name was Jyoti Singh! Judgement honors her memory

Her name was Jyoti Singh.  It’s high time for all of us to refrain from calling her Nirbhaya, Amaanat or Damini. The perpetrators and depraved minds are the ones who should be ashamed and not her or any rape victim. Victims of rape or sexual violence are ostracized and it doesn’t honor us as a society. She was one among many who are victims of rape, tortured and killed by murders who bore no shame, guilt or regret. The verdict has come after four years. It’s shameful and tragic that court verdicts take such a long time and the moment is now to implement fast-track courts to deliver justice, as pointed out by the Justice Verma Commission.

There are many victims who are shamed for no fault of them when they suffer rape at the hands of bastards who think they will get away with crime. The biggest problem is our attitudes to sexual violence and crime, albeit rape. The rape of Jyoti Singh was not just brutal and barbaric but shows our deeply enshrined sick mentality when it comes to such a heinous crime. As the learned judges have pointed out, it’s the rarest of rare cases that demand that the guilty are hanged. No civilized society can condone this violent crime where rape is all about power to control a woman. Let’s say No to this stigma called rape. The onus lie on the perpetrators and not the victim.
Image sourced from Google. Protests in India following the gruesome rape of Jyoti Singh, a paramedic student.

I hope that with this judgment, we, as a society, will stop using brainless arguments such as ‘she asked for it’, ‘was roaming at night’, ‘boys are boys and make such small mistakes’, or ‘wearing short skirts’. If any, this landmark judgment should serve as a precedent and time for us to spread awareness that if someone commits such a crime, they will be dealt severely by the law. I think this is what matters in the face of critics of death penalty arguing that it serves as no deterrent. It should be made in such a fashion that it deter crimes against women and small children. It was a case that shocked our conscience as a society where the young people showed the way by protesting against such atrocity and braved police brutality or the state’s coercion to send a loud and clear message. Enough is enough.

Yes! I was happy on hearing that the Supreme Court judges have upheld the verdict given by the High Court in the case of Jyoti Singh. I clapped. I don’t know whether the judgment brought closure since there are still some dark or far-flung corners not only in India but across the world, where the victims have dim but fading hope for justice. Perpetrators roam free. A case in point is Bilkis Bano, whose perpetrators have not been hanged. One is tempted to ask, Is it not a travesty of justice? There are so many such cases in remote villages in India where the victims lack the media exposure or the privilege of the masses fighting for them to bring media attention and the corrupt police shooing them away. We have miles to cover when victim suffer from the lack of education and awareness while at the same time, being turned down from filing FIR.  What happens to the Nirbhaya fund which is still unutilized to support rape victims?

The argument against taking a life for a life stands valid but we shouldn’t forget that this case was an exceptional one where it stood important to send a very strong statement on the need and quest for justice. Justice for Jyoti Singh. Justice for her parents who relentlessly fought for the memory of their daughter to be honored and they left no stone unturned, tirelessly doing the rounds of courts and police stations. Justice is the one thing left when everything fails and it’s where commoners build their hope in a democracy. Remember the Jessica Lall case where the media played an important part in mounting pressure to re-open the case where the accused Manu Sharma was initially let off due to his political clout!

However, the saddest part in the Jyoti Singh case is that the most violent culprit is roaming scot-free and got away with crime. The lamest excuse that the judiciary could give was that he was a minor at the time of the crime but was indeed an adult when he was released. It’s a dichotomy and irony of sort. We spoke at length on how when someone commits a crime, he is fully aware of his act and for that matter, even an 11-year-old has the mental faculty in the right to know what an action entails. Sorry, I beg to differ. For criminals, there are no repentance and not once those bastards showed remorse, as reported by the media. It’s one of the reasons why I ain’t sure whether there is closure in the gruesome rape and murder of Jyoti Singh.

The young and brilliant girl would have turned 28 on May 10. I still call her a brave heart for she fought against death in her dying moments and gave a courageous statement in front of the court magistrate. She asked that her perpetrators are punished and buried alive. As an Indian and a human being, I clap this judgment which I believe is historic and a landmark one. The judiciary had no choice but to send a strong message to criminals. A precedent has been made. Death penalty was warranted in this case. There is no second choice. As it is, the struggle doesn’t end here and lawmakers, civil society, and citizens must come together to ensure that such crimes are curbed and our daughters can roam free whether it’s during the day or night. Educate our boys to respect women as individuals but also not to suppress sex as an emotion on account of ridiculous social, religious or moral mores.

We may debate at length on death penalty but it’s the courageous parents of Jyoti Singh who went through the entire ordeal and lost their daughter to devils and vultures. Nothing can compensate their loss. Their parents may not be schooled but they had a dream for their daughter to conquer the world. Justice had been delivered in this case. As a civilized society, we cannot afford to delay or turn a deaf ear and debate on whether it will help curb crime or else it will be the biggest denial of justice. I rest my case.

We remember you, brave heart, as Jyoti Singh.




Work-in-progress, seeker and bundle of contradictions. Stubborn and Refusal to grow up and constantly in search of myself, I blurt it out on my space. Drop in and share some love. Indian by choice.

24 thoughts on “Her name was Jyoti Singh! Judgement honors her memory

  1. I would rather have them punished by dismembering their privates. That would be an apt punishment than death. It would remind them every day of their crime and they would wish death every single day. I think every such perpetrator should be meted out this treatment only.

    Shubhangi @ The Little Princess

    1. It was a case that shocked us. Yes! They should be remembered of their crime every single day and the only thing is one of them is roaming free. I agree with you. They should pay and suffer for their sins.

  2. Justice has been delivered. You clapped. But more than that you are carrying on the campaign with your blitz of words on this front. And that keeps the hope alive that one day……

    1. Thanks so much Pramod Sir. It’s our believe and we shall keep the flame burning in our hearts for a better India, a better world. We all have a jyoti inside us, the light. How you doing?

    1. Agree to that. Cannot fathom that the most violent is working anonymously in a hotel and that too the owner is kept in the dark. It’s bizarre how the state is nurturing a criminal.

  3. As a woman I am happy that the decision is taken but the time it takes in our country can break humans. Its said that patience is needed for a good life.. sometimes I just question till what time patience also has to wait for everything?

    1. Yes! The time taken by court makes it goes sometimes like justice is denied. I saw a certain pride on the face if Jyoti’s parents. It’s never easy but at least those murderers will be sent to guillotine. Yes, sometimes patience wear thin on us and we are like, whether it’s really worth it.

  4. I really don’t know whether to applause or still be skeptical. There is still a chance they might go free…who knows!
    Indian Judicial and the Political system are full of Corruption.

    If they indeed get hanged, it would only be because of the high-profile status of the case and also because of public pressure. However, there are many similar cases which are pending in courts, asking to be looked upon!

    Anyway, a step in the right direction for now!

    1. Firstly, I think the sentence has been delivered and it should be executed. But, I understand your point owing to past events. I agre to the second point made where similar cases are languishing in courts which is a real tragedy. Let’s hope fast track courts be implemented soon. Thanks for dropping Alok and sharing your insightful views.

    1. This judgment was needed and perhaps, earlier. In a way, that would save Jyoti parents energy and trauma they gone through in running to seek justice. Respect to them. Let’s hope this judgment is executed in a timely fashion and serve as an example. I still rue how Mr Minor got away and working as a free man.

  5. That was straight from the heart! And a case like this deserves nothing less because it shocked our collective conscience. A verdict should have come much earlier, but at least it came. There are many who never got justice. So this case is a victory regardless of how late it may have been delivered. Peace be with her soul. Well written, Sir 😊

    1. Thanks Pradita and coming from no less than a lawyer, it’s good to have your perspective. You rightly pointed on many who are denied justice, Pradita. I truly hail this judgment as victory for Jyoti’s soul, victims and but also her parents. Please do not call me Sir….Vishal is cool:)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s